Optical scan voting machines offer paper ballots and a bit more security than
touch screen voting machines. But a recent study of the memory cards for optical
scanners used in Connecticut's machines have experts working for the State
worried. Connecticut are using these optical scan machines despite well documented
failures.
The memory cards hold the votes and are the chief security vulnerability
in AccuVote Optical Scan voting machines. Yet, they fail routinely, and both
the manufacturer, Diebold, and regional vendor, LHS Associates, have kept the
problem quiet. But when the Secretary of State's voting machine security experts
at the University
of Connecticut tested the memory cards LHS programmed in
2007 they found high
failure rates.
We found about 3.5% of the cards defective in that way, containing junk
data being unusable. In the post election audit though the sample is smaller
we found 8% of improperly formatted cards.
Alex Shvartsman, lead investigator,
puts some perspective on the numbers.
"Suppose you used your credit card which is a similar card in size and out
of 100 transactions four transactions would be declined because of a card malfunction.
I mean I think that would be a terrible situation and people would rebel."
At
the moment there is not much chance for a popular rebellion since many voters
heading to the polls for super Tuesday have no idea that their voting machines
are unreliable. Students at a Barack Obama rally at the University of Connecticut
are excited about the upcoming election: "Have you ever heard
of the Diebold AccuVote Optical Scan machine? No, no, no, (laughter).
But these
students shuttered at the possibility of unreliable voting machines: "I
would want to know who they have a contract with because for all I know they're
gonna go in and take the machine and change the votes around."
The Secretary
of State has dragged her feet on holding the vendor, LHS, accountable. But
Deputy Secretary of State Lesley Mara suggested changes may need to be made
prior to November: "I feel like we are building and have
a system that is safe and secure and reliable especially when I compare it
to how much progress other states have been able to make to date that use the
same technology. I think that we are on the right track."
Still, a few days
before the primary registrars like West Hartford's Eleanor Brazell were just
sending failed memory cards back to the vendor without notifying officials: "All
I can tell you is West Hartford had one card fail last time and one this time
and they were returned and a new one was sent out which tested fine."
So the
state may not know how many of the memory cards failed during the primary.
But voting rights activists are hoping to use upcoming hearings with members
of the State Legislature to try to fix this and other problems before November's
Presidential Election.
You will find audio, video, blogs, and hard-hitting analysis from progressive journalists. Each day, unravel the double speak of candidates and media pundits, with news and alternative perspectives about the critical issues.
this site is a partnership of Pacifica Radio and Free Speech Radio News
This website, and its content are the rights and efforts of Pacifica Radio and Free Speech Radio News. This effort is a special project for the 2008 US elections, both the national election and local elections; focusing on the issues that matter most to voters: the Iraq War; Foreign Policy; Health Care; the Environment; Labor; Education, and more.