Home Issues Foreign Policy Election Unspun Pilot - Iraq Position Examined
Election Unspun Pilot - Iraq Position Examined
Written by Leigh Ann Caldwell   
Monday, 28 January 2008 00:00
Unspun Pilot - January 21, 2008
produced by Leigh Ann Caldwell, and Nathan Moore
[?]

Of the remaining candidates, the Iraq war remains an important, yet not central, part of their candidacy.

In his speech after the New Hampshire primary, Barack Obama had only this mention of the war, yet his reference excited his supporters.

... and when I am President, we will end this war in Iraq and bring the troops home ...

His troop home now message would remove up to 6000 troops per month, saying all combat troops would be out by the end of his first year in office. Under his strategic reduction, about 50,000 non-combat troops would still be in the country at the beginning of 2010, assisting in volatile regions with the intention of continuing reductions. Obama does not talk about removing the hundreds of thousands of American contractors in Iraq.

He would deploy at least 7,000 of those troops to Afghanistan and leave some in neighboring countries in case of an Al Qaeda insurgence.

Obama gave a speech as Illinois State Senator in 2002, just three weeks after the Senate gave President Bush war authorization. He called the war dumb, an predicted a long occupation that would drain US resources and lives.

 


Meanwhile, Democrat John Edwards, who voted for authorization for the war as US Senator in 2002, has since apologized for what he calls a mistake. He released a more aggressive withdrawal timetable in recent weeks.

... I will withdraw the troops with in 10 months. I will promise to do that because we have to win this war in Iraq ...

In his new plan, he calls an immediate withdrawal. He is the most specific on the number of troops that he says will stay in Iraq. 4 – 5000 troops will remain to protect the Embassy and possibly for humanitarian workers.

He too says troops will stay in the neighboring counties and some will be transferred to Afghanistan.

 


Hillary Clinton also supported the war and was the last of the democratic candidates to announce her opposition. She provides the fewest details on her Iraq plan. She says troops will start coming home with in 60 days. But she doesn't talk about an end game. She says she will listen to her military commanders to help guide the withdrawal. She implied a cautious Iraq agenda at this speech in New Hampshire.

... to deliver on the promise that we'll have the will and the wisdom to end the war in Iraq the right way ...

All the candidates talk about a diplomatic strategy. Edwards and Obama implicitly state they will work with Iran and Syria to help stabilize the country. Clinton's plan implies that she'll do so.

 


Meanwhile on the Republican side, Senator John McCain said he'd keep troops in Iraq for 100 years if he has to.

FSRN asked McCain if that position could hurt him in the general election if he were to be the nominee.

His response;

... I'd rather loose a political battle than give up my principles ...

 


Meanwhile, anti-war groups will continue to put pressure on candidates to make Iraq a central part of their campaign.

To look a bit deeper into the Democratic candidate's Iraq war policy. Life-long anti-war activist and author of "Ending the War in Iraq", Tom Hayden, talks about what the Democratic presidential candidates' don't talk about in their Iraq policies. Hayden begins by analyzing the political forces he feels are influencing the candidates. This interview was done by KPFK producer Suzi Weissman.

 

Add your comment

Your name:
Subject:
Comment:
  The word for verification. Lowercase letters only with no spaces.
Word verification:

About Election Unspun

You will find audio, video, blogs, and hard-hitting analysis from progressive journalists. Each day, unravel the double speak of candidates and media pundits, with news and alternative perspectives about the critical issues.

This election year, the community radio network, Pacifica Radio and the community radio news service, Free Speech Radio News bring you grassroots voices left out by corporate-sponsored media.

Top Videos

Presidential Debate Remix

Watch Video

Healthcare and Medicaid

Watch Video

No Handshake Non-Scandal

Watch Video

McKinney Announces Run

Watch Video

The Real Democrat

Watch Video

Message from Clinton

Watch Video

Fighting for One America

Watch Video

Obama on the Iraq War

Watch Video

Gravel On the Iraq War

Watch Video

Related Items

ElectionUnspun Poll

Do you typically vote?
 

Syndicate This

this site is a partnership of Pacifica Radio and Free Speech Radio News

This website, and its content are the rights and efforts of Pacifica Radio and Free Speech Radio News. This effort is a special project for the 2008 US elections, both the national election and local elections; focusing on the issues that matter most to voters: the Iraq War; Foreign Policy; Health Care; the Environment; Labor; Education, and more.

If you have any ideas for future segments, click here to send us that information. If you feedback for the site editors,click here to send us a message. If you have technical comments or require help or comments, click here to reach our technical staff.